Ruehl No.925 Cologne

As weird as it might sound, most women like a cologne that reminds them of their dad or grandpa. Ruehl No.925 Cologne ($68; Ruehl stores only) definitely has such a smell. The cologne has a strong, musky-yet-modern aroma that's attractive enough that every Ruehl store is required to spray the scent on every article of clothing in the store.